Nostalgia isn’t what it used to be
Oct 6th, 2008 | By Scoop | Category: Foreign Affairs, Politics, Economics, & Public Policy, The BlogHanging around outside the conference of Britain’s governing Labour party, I was handed a leaflet declaring that the “crisis of capitalism” was upon us. A nostalgic glow came over me. It brought back fond memories of a time when Marxism was fashionable and capitalism’s nemesis was always just around the corner. Alas, like the many Millennial sects who have predicted the end of the world once too often, most Marxists seem to have drifted off and will probably miss the coming Apocalypse.
You have to go back a long way to find a time when capitalism faced its previous systemic crisis. We are not talking about mere 1970s-style crises here; a difficult time but one where the fundamentals held steady. We have to look back almost beyond living memory; indeed, before John McCain was born. Now, that’s what I call ancient history.
The Great Depression brought us financial misery and political upheaval and led, indirectly, to the Second World War. When crisis hits, some people go for the familiar and secure; others turn to extremes. There is no way of telling with certainty which way it will fall.
The problem with historical parallels is that they only work with hindsight. Predicting the future involves more than a little guesswork even if it is wrapped up in learned analysis. If by chance some would-be dictator sporting a dodgy mustache should show up blaming the global financial crisis on a Zionist conspiracy, we might hope that the Europeans would be more sensible this time than to elect him into office. The omens are not good, however; last week, 29% of Austrian voters gave their support to two far-right parties, a combined total that matched the support of the Social Democratic Party and surpassed that of the conservative People’s Party.

