The Conservatism of Tomorrow
Nov 7th, 2008 | By E.D. Kain | Category: Culture, Society, & Religion, Featured, US PoliticsIn 1980 Ronald Reagan swept into office and effectively re-invented American politics and American conservatism, ushering in an age of supply-side economics, deregulation, and substantial tax cuts. He united conservatives and some democrats with his social agenda, and won the hearts of as many Americans through his genial nature and oratorical skills as he did with his politics.
But that was then, and now we have watched the past eight years of Bush-era Conservatism lead to huge escalation in the size of the Federal government; the mismanagement (until recently) of two wars; and public support of conservative policies dwindling. We face an Obama Presidency which in and of itself I am not terribly concerned with, but we also face a huge Democratic majority in Congress, and a possible 60-seat Democratic Senate.
I really like checks and balances, so this prospect is frightening.
Now, I realize we’ve been in the last throes of a rather ugly, depressing Presidential race. Conservatives have broken into several camps during these past months. There are those who have disavowed Sarah Palin and jumped ship; those who have stuck to digging up dirt on Obama; those who have argued the merits of the McCain/Palin ticket; and those who have written off the election and have begun to think about the future of the Republican Party and American Conservatism in general.
Many conservative writers have already begun this process, from David Frum or David Brooks, to the editorial staff at Culture11 (read Tory! Tory! Tory! and Coming Up Conservative. Ross Douthat penned an article two years ago that dealt with this issue, The Party of Sam’s Club.
Now, not all these writers and commentators agree on each issue, but they do all share in common the notion that it’s time for Conservatism to adapt, change, evolve, and re-fashion itself as a more competitive brand, a safer, more appealing alternative to the Big Government of the Liberals. After all, following the last 8 years, conservatives can hardly claim to be the party of Limited Government, can we?
David Brooks and many of these others write that we need to re-take the Center. I would agree. I am a centrist-conservative to begin with, but I think even for those more conservative than I, the obvious truth must be that the vast majority of Americans don’t adhere strictly to either Big Government Liberalism or to any orthodox free-market capitalism. The arguments against supply-side economics are getting more plentiful and persuasive. Unfortunately, the alternative presented is a liberal one rather than a conservative. We risk allowing the country to veer far left rather than take it a bit closer to the center.
Douthat argues for a more family-focused conservatism, which places some emphasis on health care and on family-friendly taxes–no tax on those earning under $100,000; larger tax credits for children; a “consumption” tax to encourage savings, and so forth. He argues also for some sort of GI Bill type college tuition reimbursement program for stay-at-home moms.
David Frum and others argue for carbon taxes to replace other more invasive personal taxes. Bill Harrison mentioned this in his Rove article this week as well, arguing that Carbon Taxes could replace at least a portion of FICA taxes. This is one way the conservative movement can also be a green movement.
I would argue that now is the time to begin thinking about these things. Let’s move away from this notion of tax-cuts, and toward the many very good ideas on tax reform. With smart reform, we might have better luck lowering taxes. With family-friendly policies, we might have better luck with the average voter–after all, to the young family of four making $70,000 a year, perhaps hearing that you will not have to fill out a tax return at all will motivate you to vote more than hearing about some big tax cut for the enormously wealthy. This is the logic, I realize, that Obama is using, but he only goes half the distance. He still has his policies wrapped up in regulation, spreading wealth, etc, whereas a conservative policy would focus on business growth, family, and smart reforms of complex and unnecessary government organizations like the IRS.
Conservatives also need to give up the “deregulation” talk. It has become a dirty word. Let’s talk about reforming old regulations for a new century, and then let’s evaluate where deregulation has worked, and where it hasn’t. Let’s also talk about oversight. Limited Government can still very effectively use oversight rather than oppressive regulation, intended to prevent collapses like the one we’re experiencing, but without the oftentimes costly effects of government interference.
I also believe that social conservatives would do well to shift their focus away from gay marriage and the never-ending abortion debate and focus on real-world policies that effect the American family. Education, health care, tax reform, these are all social-issues, and they can all be applied through the lens of the American family. Some of the ideas I mentioned above are as much matters for fiscal conservatives as they are for social conservatives. (Oh, and fiscal conservative doesn’t have to be an oxymoron anymore!)
I will wrap this up.
The point I’m making is that conservatism, in so many ways, needs to let the past go to some extent, and start thinking about the future. Conservatism, perhaps due to the negative incantations of its most popular radio and TV pundits, perhaps due to the unnecessary secrecy of the Bush/Cheney administration, has become a cynical and unpleasant movement. I can barely read half the conservative blogs these days, they have become so hopeless, so negative. Isn’t it time we decided to make Conservatism the party of Individuality, Reason, and Hope? Can’t we woo the younger voters by appealing to that very American quality of self-determination? Appeal to the American family by pushing policies that will actually help the American family? And appeal to the entrepreneurs of America by pushing policies that will free them to do business the way they see fit?
Conservatism has lost its way. It is time we went out into the wild and meditated for a while. Let’s talk about the future.



